Saturday 16 May 2015

Trip Report: Sikkim and Mahananda Part I

A Visit to Paradise!

A birding trip report of Sikkim and Mahananda, April 1-9, 2015

PART 1

Sikkim had always been among the top birding destinations on my bucket list. Year after year, images of amazing birds from this tiny kingdom had my mouth watering and I had vowed to visit it, not only to bird but also to experience the spectacular natural beauty of the place. I had been planning a trip since 2013, but due to various reasons, it could not take place till this year. In February, Rajneesh messaged me asking whether I was interested in a trip to Sikkim. I became quite excited and asked the usual suspects whether they could join me. But alas, due to family and work obligations they were unable to make it and the prospects looked grim. Into the void stepped Anuj and Ameya, who agreed almost immediately to join and so the four of us, Rajneesh included, started making plans. Flights were an issue, and the debate was whether to fly from Pune or Mumbai. In the end, Mumbai won out as it was the cheaper option. Tickets booked, we were eagerly awaiting D-day. But then, the weather gods decided to play spoilsport and unseasonal rains started all over the country. Sikkim was not spared and we were staring at the possibility of the trip being a washout. So with fervent prayers on our lips, we boarded the flight to Bagdogra from Mumbai. Rajneesh had reached a day earlier and would go birding nearby.

The flight to Bagdogra via Guwahati was the most boring flight in my life. The three of us hadn’t got seats together so I spent 3 hours attempting to sleep or listening to music. A lot of people got off the plane at Guwahati which gave us the chance to sit together till Bagdogra. The flight to Bagdogra from Guwahati was joyfully spent sighting (imaginary) Satyr Tragopans, Baikal Teals and Greater Adjutants, all from the airplane window.

Rajneesh picked us up at Bagdogra and informed us about his excursion to Mahananda earlier in the day, He had sighted a Blue-bearded Bee-eater, Jungle Owlets, Black-crested Bulbuls and Greater-necklaced Laughingthrush in a single session in good weather, which cheered us up considerably.
The journey to Aritar was long and tedious. The sightings along the road were few, with only Black and Black-crested Bulbuls, a Black-rumped Flameback and plenty of Assamese Macaques to start our list. We reached Aritar at night, after facing rain, fog and blocked roads. After dinner, we went to bed, hoping that tomorrow would be better and we could finally start properly birding.
The next morning we woke up to overcast skies and the calls of Himalayan and Eurasian Cuckoos. After hurriedly getting ready, we set out hoping to get new species and good images. We birded in the surroundings of our homestay and were rewarded with good views of Chestnut-crowned and Striated Laughingthrushes, Rufous Sibia, Russet Sparrow, Blue-capped Rock Thrush, Spangled Drongo, Grey Bushchat and Green-backed Tit. A couple of female redstarts also popped up and we later identified as Hodgson’s and Black Redstarts. Our homestay was located above Aritar Lake so we decided to walk down the trail to the lake. This proved to be very fruitful as we ticked off Whistler’s and Grey-cheeked Warblers, Himalayan Bulbuls, Blue Whistling Thrushes, Great Barbets, an Ashy Drongo and a Verditer Flycatcher. We came to an open patch in the otherwise canopy covered region to find a pair of Asian Barred Owlets being mobbed by Grey-chinned Minivets, a single male Rufous-gorgeted Flycatcher, a mixed hunting party of Black-chinned Yuhinas, Grey-throated Babblers and Grey-hooded Warblers. On going ahead, Rajneesh spotted some skulkers and exclaimed, “Laughingthrush!” We tried hard to focus our lenses/binocs at the location he pointed out. I got fleeting views of a Black-faced Laughingthrush when suddenly a rare Blue-winged Laughingthrush came out in the open! It sat there for about 2 seconds and then disappeared into the undergrowth. Happy that we had seen a highly prized bird, we proceeded towards the lake. The rest of the journey gave us Greater and Lesser Yellownape, a flock of White-crested Laughingthrushes, Lemon-rumped, Buff-barred and Western-crowned Warblers, Red-tailed and Chestnut-tailed Minla, Grey Treepie, White-tailed Nuthatch and White-bellied Erpornis. Satisfied with our morning session, we went for breakfast. Post breakfast, we packed our bags and left for Zuluk, via Rongli and Padamchen. 

We had several birding halts along the way, adding Mountain Bulbul, Scarlet Minivet, Little Swift, Himalayan Swiftlet and the tricolor race of the Long-tailed Shrike to our list. A halt to check on a calling cuckoo proved particularly fruitful as we chanced upon a big mixed hunting party. There were so many birds that each of us tended to focus on a different individual to id it. By the time the next person tried to find it another had taken its place, leading to confusion and arguments about the exact id!  In the midst of all that, we conclusively ided Buff-barred, Whistler’s, Yellow-throated and Hume’s Leaf Warblers, Chestnut-bellied and Velvet-fronted Nuthatches, Pale Blue Flycatcher, Grey-headed Canary Flycatcher and White-bellied Erpornis. The cuckoo turned out to be a Large Hawk Cuckoo with an odd call. Happy with our haul, we proceeded to Rongli for permission to visit Zuluk.
Slender-billed Scimitar Babbler
At Rongli we ran into a problem.  Our original plan was to travel via Zuluk upto Lungthung and stay there for a couple of days. The police declined permission to even visit Lungthung, and gave us permits uptil Zuluk only. We pleaded to no avail. Glumly we set off for Zuluk, brainstorming about how to spend the extra days which we now had. The overcast conditions and fog along the way did not help our mood and sightings were few and far in between. A single Besra just before Padamchen lifted our spirits for a while. When we reached Padamchen, though, our luck changed. We were stopping intermittently, checking bamboos for parrotbills, when movement in a small bush caught our attention. Fulvettas! A trio of White-browed Fulvettas was busy foraging for insects and we photographed them to our heart’s content. On walking ahead I got a glimpse of a male White-tailed Robin fanning his tail, but he got spooked by my presence and fled into the undergrowth. On walking ahead, Rajneesh spotted a Greater Necklaced Laughingthrush which eluded the rest of us. Green-tailed Sunbirds, Rufous-gorgeted and Taiga Flycatchers, Rufous-capped Babblers, a Blue-fronted Redstart and more White-browed Fulvettas kept us occupied. Encouraged by these sightings in spite of the weather, we drove onward when Rajneesh suddenly shouted, “Scimitar-babbler!” We quickly got down from the vehicle and waited patiently for the bird to show itself, and show itself it did! A spectacular Slender-billed Scimitar Babbler came out in the open, bubbling away on a bare branch. We proceeded to click as many pictures as we could, not believing our luck. After a few minutes it departed, leaving us elated. The fun wasn’t over, however. A few feet ahead in a patch of bamboo, Black-throated Parrotbills were buzzing and we got excellent views of those as well. Two great lifers in a matter of minutes!! With our moods soaring, we reached Zuluk by 17.00. This was our halt for the next two nights.
Black-throated Parrotbill




Zuluk and beyond is dominated by the Indian Army. It is basically a transit and acclimatization area for forces travelling to the border. The tourism in the area has developed much later. Our homestay was a wood and aluminium construct and the wind rattled the metal sheets of our room. There were many people living in the homestay, each group having 1-2 rooms depending on the number of people. The four of us shared a room with two double beds and an attached bathroom. After dumping our luggage, we went for lunch, being utterly famished. After ravenously finishing lunch (at 17.15!) and promising to come back for tea in half an hour we set out for a bit of evening birding around the homestay area. Grey Bushchat and Blue-fronted Redstarts were the only birds we spotted along with a friendly Pika, so we called it day and turned in.
Golden-breasted Fulvetta
The next day we decided to go back down to Rongli and see if we could get permission to stay for atleast one day at Lungthung. As usual, we had intermittent birding stops along the way. The first stop yielded a pair of Slender-billed Scimitar Babblers, Rufous-winged Fulvettas and Green-tailed Sunbirds. Further stops gave us White-browed Fulvettas, a shy Chestnut-headed Tesia, Whistler’s and Green-crowned Warblers. A lone Greater Spotted Eagle circled above. As we descended, we reached a bend with extensive bamboo patches on both sides of the road. Ameya spotted a couple of large birds moving about in the bamboo. “Brown Parrotbills!” he exclaimed, and we stared at these big, plain, mean looking birds. They looked like the hoodlum cousins of parakeets, the ones their parents must’ve told to stay away from. As we clicked away, more birds popped up. This particular patch turned out to be a goldmine. Whiskered Yuhinas and White-browed Fulvettas were plentiful. A female Scarlet Minivet was perched high on a conifer. A pair of Himalayan Bluetails came onto the road, searching for food. A friendly Chestnut-tailed Minla ate berries at quite close range. Golden-breasted Fulvettas flitted through the bamboo like tiny topazes. A shy Barred Cuckoo-Dove gave fleeting looks. A Grey-headed Bullfinch sat feeding with some minlas. A Great Parrotbill kept calling but did not show itself. A Grey-winged Blackbird perched on top of a tree confused us for some time, until we realized that the ‘extremely long tail’ seen was actually a leaf. Cheered up after such a great morning, we drove down towards Rongli. Anuj was desperate to shoot Spotted Forktails, so we stopped and checked every stream along the way in hopes of finding one. Just before Rongli, we came across a large stream and Anuj yelled,”Forktail!” It turned out to not the Spotted, but a dainty Little Forktail. It was quite patient and allowed us very good views. A pair of Plumbeous Redstarts flitted among the rocks. Rajneesh spotted movement downstream and we peered at it through our binocs. Silver-eared Mesia! A pair of mesias, along with a Hill Prinia was moving about in the bushes surrounding the stream. Striated Laughingthrushes called from the adjoining slopes. Having added these lifers, we moved on.

Little Forktail
Our visit to Rongli turned out to be fruitful and we got permission to stay for a day at Lungthung. This gave us hope of getting some high altitude birds which we would’ve otherwise dipped on. We proceeded back to Zuluk via Padamchen, adding Orange-bellied Leafbird, Fire-breasted Flowepecker, Rufous-bellied Niltava, Pygmy Wren-Babbler and Rufous-breasted Accentor along the way.          
The next morning we travelled to Lungthung and Nathang Valley. The soldiers from the nearby Army camp were preparing to travel uphill as well, so we had to hide our photographic equipment for some time. Birding was scarce early on, with Common Buzzards, Fire-tailed Sunbirds and Rosy Pipits being seen. As sunlight fell covered more of the rhododendron covered slopes, activity started picking up. A mixed hunting party of Stripe throated and Rufous-vented Yuhinas along with a single Dark-rumped Rosefinch provided great views. A Black Kite (lineatus?) had us scrambling for images thinking it was some other raptor. We also had excellent views of a pair of Fire-tailed Myzornis foraging in the undergrowth. This bird was high on my wishlist and all of us had a big smile on our faces by the time the birds flew away. We stopped for tea and Maggi at Thambi point just before Lungthung. The point provides a beautiful panoramic view of Zuluk and the surrounding region, with Mt. Kanchenjunga at the backdrop. As we sat on the edge, eating our irritatingly salty Maggi, a flock of about 50 Fire-tailed Sunbirds flew uphill along the cliff edges. Happy that we were getting birds so easily, we sat sipping our tea, having kept or lenses in the car. Little did we know that this was just the start. As the temperature starting rising, so did the raptors. A pair of Common Buzzards circled over us, before going higher. They were followed by a pair of Upland Buzzards which made us run to get our lenses. The Uplands were followed in close succession by 4 Steppe Eagles and surprisingly, a Pallas’s Fish Eagle. It was amazing to see these big raptors gain altitude slowly. First we viewed them from above, then they were at eye level and then they went higher so we saw their underparts. The Pallas’ did not follow the Steppes over the mountains but just climbed up and turned away to a different direction. The Pallas’s Fish Eagle is a resident breeder so I was puzzled as to why it was migrating with the Steppes.
The view from Thambi point, with Mt. Kanchenjunga in the background

The Steppes and Pallas’s were followed by a dark morph Booted Eagle, which is an uncommon sight so far east. It is regularly seen in western India, but apparently not so common in the eastern parts. A largish Accipiter made me go on a shooting spree, thinking it was a lifer. It turned out to be a male Eurasian Sparrowhawk.  Common Kestrels joined the party as well. We were all excited by these sightings and moved onward toward our homestay so that we could dump our luggage. On the way Rajneesh and Anuj spotted a Hen Harrier and a pale Northern Goshawk, both of which I missed as I was on the other side of the car. We moved onward towards Nathang valley and Kubuk. Kubuk is essentially the Indo-China border, so the Army has a pervading presence everywhere. Bunkers and rest areas are dotted along the way and supply trucks frequently dominate the narrow roads. Soon we hit the snowline and reveled in the magnificent whiteness of it all. We took a break from birding and played around in snow, clobbering each other with snowballs. After being reminded by Rajneesh that we still had some way to go, we got back in the car. There wasn’t much birding on the road to Nathang and Kubuk and we only saw some Blue-fronted Redstarts, Olive backed and Rosy Pipits. But the view was simply spectacular!

After having a mandatory hot cup of tea at Kubuk, we returned to Lungthung. On the way Anuj spotted some white dots on the banks of the Elephant Lake at Kubuk. These turned out to be a flock of Common Shelducks! A thorough scan of the lake revealed a few pairs of Ruddy Shelducks and a single gull, possibly Brown/Black-headed. The lake itself, with its deep blue water was stunning! The homestay at Lungthung turned out to be a single room with a double bed and an attached toilet for the four of us. The four of us would never have fit there so we asked for an extra room. The adjacent rooms were locked and reserved for someone else. The owner promised us that if the other people did not arrive by evening, the room would be ours. So having crossed our fingers, we went for lunch.

Himalayan Monal male
Among our many targets at Lungthung was the Himalayan Monal. The locals informed us that the male was a regular visitor to the rocky slopes in front of our homestay. We asked some locals to inform us immediately once it was seen. Soon enough, our driver called us to show the magnificent male sitting on a rock. We scrambled for photos, even crawling down the slope to get closer, but the monal disappeared. However our efforts were rewarded by the sight of a Yellow-throated Marten drinking water down below. Happy about the sighting but disappointed about the lack of photographs, we returned to our room.  An hour later, our driver again called to inform us that the male was once again perched on the rock, but much closer. This time we used a longer route to get closer and successfully captured the beautiful bird in our frame.

Thursday 8 January 2015

Book Review: Birds of India, Pakistan,Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, the Andaman and Nicobar Islands and the Maldives by Norman Arlott

Opening a new bird book is always an exciting prospect. There is always an anticipation of new id pointers to be gained, new illustrations to be appreciated and taxonomy updates to understand. It was with this anticipation that I opened my copy of Birds of India, Pakistan, Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka by Norman Arlott. I was already frustrated with this book as the delivery was 3 months late due to issues with the supplier. I had placed my order on 6th October 2014 and I received it on the 7th of January 2015. I genuinely hoped that the book would be worth the wait.
The author is a renowned bird artist and has illustrated field guides to birds of North America, West Indies and East Africa in addition to preparing illustrated checklists for Europe and Russia.
I got the hardcover version, which is nicely compact and has an image of the Malabar Barbet on the cover. The author states that his brief was to produce an illustrated checklist and not an ultimate field guide which was a bit disappointing as I expected a full field guide. He has also clarified that he has not illustrated juvenile plumages in order to ‘keep the book to manageable size’. I wish birding in real life would involve only adult individuals.
The description for each species includes short behavioral notes, description of juvenile plumage, call, habitat and distribution. No pointers for separation between similar species have been stated, which will prove troublesome for beginners. Species such as eagles, accipiters, waders, Phylloscopus and Acrocephalus warblers, pipits and larks require specific id pointers which are not apparent by looking at illustrations, especially to beginners.
The illustrations do not include flight profiles for species such as ducks, geese, cranes, waders, terns and gulls. This may be confusing for identifying overflying birds in wetlands. The lack of juvenile plumages means that members of the Accipiteridae family in particular will be a nightmare to identify. Phylloscopus plates have no illustrations for worn plumages in which they are seen especially in winters. The Blyth’s and Blue-eared Kingfisher plates look pretty much the same, just with a different coloured beak. The illustrations are not as good as the ones from Grimmett et al. However this is a personal opinion.
A big aggravation in Grimmett et al (1999) was that the distribution map for a particular species was not on the same page as the page. The author seems to have ignored that as all distribution maps are at the end of the book which is annoying for me. There are no maps for vagrant species as well as for pelagic which is irritating. Some maps are downright hilarious. There is no distribution of White-bellied Heron in Bhutan or Eastern Imperial Eagle in NW India. Many such mistakes abound. Map for the Red-backed Shrike is absent even though it is a passage migrant. The European Roller is shown from just two locations in India. There is no distribution shown in the map for the southern race of the Mountain Hawk Eagle (N.n.keelarti) even though the text mentions it. Such mistakes spoil the quality of the book.
New records of Godlewski’s Bunting, Derbyan Parakeet, Elliot’s Laughingthrush, Black-headed Greenfinch and Black-browed Tit have been illustrated although they have been mentioned as doubtful and have no maps. Yunnan Nuthatch and Mugimaki Flycatcher, however, haven’t been mentioned at all.
Pet peeves with both this book and Grimmett et al include no distribution of the Common Buzzard and Eurasian Sparrowhawk in Maharashtra. This needs to be rectified ASAP.
Overall I would not recommend this book for anyone seriously interested in birding. It has too many flaws as the author has skipped a lot of important stuff to keep the book compact. Kasmierczak (2000) and Grimmett el al (2011) are much better overall, even with their flaws.

This book is available at Flipkart http://www.flipkart.com/birds-india-collins-field-guide-english/p/itmdwyf8jtdnghht?pid=9780007429554&otracker=from-search&srno=t_11&query=birds&ref=67b27b2d-3c67-4681-ac75-134d256c6fdf

Amazon http://www.amazon.in/Birds-India-Collins-Field-Guide/dp/000742955X/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1420710743&sr=1-1

If you like birding and are on Facebook, join my group Birds of Pune https://www.facebook.com/groups/punebirds/